How Far Does the Evidence of Sources 11 and 12 Support the Judgement of the Hunter Committee Presented in Source 10?

blood lines 11 and 12 both share a homogeneous view, compared to the one put across in germ 10 by the hunting watch Committees report from 1919.
This is because Source 10 was taken from a report published by the Hunter Committee (a group of British Lawyers) in 1919. The consultation suggests that the Hunter Committee matt-up Dyers figureions were beyond what every reasonable man would have thought to be needed. This shows that the British lawyers were questioning the means of a British soldier. The Hunter Committee did not agree with the opinion that Dyers actions relieve the Punjab and averted a large-scale rebellion in fact they felt that since there was no sign of a conspiracy to depose the British Raj, it was extreme and unreasonable to open fire into the crowd.
Source 11, which is from General Dyers account of the events at Amritsar, and Source 12 both support Source 10 to some extent. This is shown by the fact that they recognise the loss of life that occurred on the thirteenth of April 1919. If the Hunter Committee in Source 10 is clear when they say that it is not proven that any conspiracy had been organise to overthrow British power. then it does suggest that Dyers act of violence that killed so many innocent people was unnecessary.




however the other side of the argument is the view that Dyers actions were necessary as displayed in Source 11 and 12. In Source 11, Dyer claimed that he felt it was necessary to react quickly considering the small surface of his force and that to hesitate might induce attack. This suggests that his actions were teara port(a) as source 10 hinted by saying he acted beyond the necessity of the case but Dyer himself saw it as being essential, considering the attacks that had taken place the previous days, and in this leave out defends his actions. Also he refers to the people gathered in the Jallianwala Bagh as a mob and he felt the only way to diffuse the situation was to use violence, but unfortunately this caused nearly 200-300 unnecessary...If you want to get a full essay, order it on our website: Orderessay



If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my essay .